← Book
The Other Dunn SisterCh. 2 of 14 · free 1–3

FreeCh. 2 of 14 · free 1–3

Chapter 2

Three days later, I was back in Charlotte's house, folding Lily's laundry like a ghost no one acknowledged.

Charlotte had taken over the master bedroom with Nate months ago—"for the baby preparations," she'd said, as if preparing for a baby required sleeping with my husband.

I'd been relocated to the guest room at the end of the hall. The one with the broken heater and the window that didn't quite shut.

"Audrey?" Charlotte's voice floated from the nursery. Sweet. Practiced. "Can you bring me the burp cloths? Lily just spit up everywhere."

I grabbed the cloths and walked in.

Charlotte sat in the glider—the one I'd picked out—with Lily nestled against her chest. Nate stood behind her, one hand on her shoulder, scrolling his phone with the other.

They looked like a magazine cover. New Parents: A Love Story.

I handed Charlotte the cloth. My fingers brushed Lily's head—soft, impossibly warm—and something inside me clenched so hard I almost gasped.

"Careful," Charlotte said lightly, shifting Lily away from my touch. "She's just settled down. Don't overstimulate her."

Don't overstimulate her.

I gave birth to her. My body made her. My blood fed her for nine months. But I couldn't touch her head without permission.

"Sorry," I murmured.

Nate didn't even look up.

That night, I heard Lily crying at 2 a.m. A sharp, desperate wail that cut through walls. I was on my feet before I was fully awake, muscle memory from nine months of midnight kicks.

I padded to the nursery. Charlotte wasn't there.

Lily lay in her crib, face red, fists clenched, screaming.

I picked her up. She quieted almost instantly—her tiny body curling into mine like she recognized the heartbeat she'd grown inside.

"Shh," I whispered. "I'm here. Mama's here."

The word slipped out before I could stop it. Mama.

"What are you doing?"

Charlotte stood in the doorway, robe untied, hair wild. Behind her, Nate appeared, eyes narrow with sleep and suspicion.

"She was crying," I said. "No one came."

"I was coming," Charlotte snapped, crossing the room and taking Lily from my arms. "You can't just waltz in here and pick her up whenever you want. She needs to bond with me. The pediatrician said skin-to-skin contact with the mother is critical in the first week."

The mother.

I bit the inside of my cheek until I tasted iron.

"You're confusing her," Charlotte continued, rocking Lily with exaggerated tenderness. "She needs consistency. One primary caregiver."

"She was screaming," I said quietly.

Nate stepped forward. "Charlotte's right. You signed the agreement, Audrey. You're the surrogate. That was the deal. You can't keep inserting yourself like this."

Inserting myself. Into my own daughter's life.

"I carried her," I said, my voice barely above a whisper.

"And we're grateful," Nate said, the word grateful landing like a slap. "But it's time to start transitioning. You knew this was coming."

Transitioning. Like I was a temp employee being phased out.

Charlotte softened her voice—the way she always did when she wanted to sound reasonable while being cruel. "Audrey, maybe it would be good for you to start looking at apartments? Just so you have your own space. We'll always be family, but… Lily needs a stable environment."

Translation: Get out.

I looked at Lily, now quiet in Charlotte's arms, her tiny fingers wrapped around Charlotte's thumb.

"Okay," I said.

I turned and walked back to my room—the one with the broken heater—and sat on the edge of the bed.

My phone buzzed.

My lawyer: "Court date set. Two weeks. Genetic testing will be court-ordered. Once the results come back, the surrogacy contract is void. Full custody hearing follows."

Two weeks.

I just needed to survive two more weeks in this house without breaking.

I typed back: "They're already trying to push me out. Telling me I can't hold her."

His reply: "Document everything. Every conversation. Every restriction. Judges love patterns."

I opened the voice memo app and pressed record.

Then I placed the phone on my nightstand, screen down, and waited.

Because Charlotte and Nate always came to deliver their cruelest lines right before bed—when they thought I was too tired to fight back.

And tonight, I wanted every word on tape.

Next chapter

FreeCh. 3 · Chapter 3

Opens in the reader.

Previous

Ch. 2 of 14 · free 1–3 · 14% of book · 0% of chapter

Next chapter